Friday, April 20, 2012

In Shakespeare's comedy As You Like It, why does Celia suggest that she and Rosalind should change fathers?

In Act I, Scene 3 of William Shakespeare's comedy
As You Like It, Celia, daughter of Duke Frederick, suggests that
she would be willing to exchange her father with the father of Rosalind, Celia's cousin
and daughter of the previous, rightful Duke, whom Frederick has overthrown. Frederick,
fearing that Rosalind is becoming too popular with the populace, wrongfully accuses her
of treason and orders her to leave his court and join her banished father. When Celia
protests, the following exchange
occurs:



  • FREDERICK
    You are a fool. You, niece, provide yourself.
    If you outstay
    the time, upon mine honour,
    And in the greatness of my word, you die.

Exeunt DUKE and
LORDS


  • CELIA O my
    poor Rosalind! Whither wilt thou go? 495
    Wilt thou change fathers? I will give
    thee mine.
    I charge thee be not thou more griev'd than I am.


Celia’s response
is significant for a number of reasons:


  • It
    indicates her deep disapproval of her father’s
    behavior.

  • It indicates the depth of her love for
    Rosalind.

  • It indicates some sympathy on her part for
    Rosalind’s banished father.

  • It helps raise the issue of
    love, a major theme of this play.

  • It helps prepare us for
    her willingness to follow Rosalind into exile.

  • It helps
    introduce the theme of change in a play that will be all about change, including changes
    of costume and character.

  • It shows her capacity for
    sympathy.

  • It helps establish her as one the virtuous
    characters in the play.

  • It reinforces our already
    negative reaction to Frederick: if he has lost the sympathy of his own virtuous
    daughter, he deserves no sympathy from us.

  • It implies
    that Celia, not her father, is the character who possesses a true sense of
    “honor.”

  • It helps us realize that it is Frederick, not
    his daughter, who is the true “fool” in this scene.

  • It
    helps prepare us for a play in which female characters will often show a good deal of
    independence, initiative, and virtue

No comments:

Post a Comment

What accomplishments did Bill Clinton have as president?

Of course, Bill Clinton's presidency will be most clearly remembered for the fact that he was only the second president ever...