The whole point of the 4th Amendment is to prevent the
government from arresting or searching people without having a good reason to do so. We
do not want a government that is allowed to arrest or search people whenever a police
officer feels like it. This is why the rule that you have mentioned has survived to the
present day.
The basic rule for arrests is that a police
officer must either have a warrant or there must be some sort of emergency that makes it
important that the officer make the arrest right then, without taking the time to get a
warrant. If warrantless arrests were legal outside of emergency situations, the 4th
Amendment would be meaningless with regard to arrests. Warrantless arrests within a
person's own home would be even more offensive because a person generally has a
reasonable expectation of privacy while inside his or her own
home.
So, this rule has survived to the present because A)
the requirement that police have a warrant is the basis of the 4th Amendment and B)
because a person's home is his/her "castle;" the place in which he or she has the
greatest reason to expect privacy.
No comments:
Post a Comment